"Gay Cake" row results in most expensive cake in UK history

Our Employment team comment on the controversial cake case

In Lee v Ashers Baking Company Ltd., four years after the case began, the Supreme Court decisively ruled that the bakery's refusal to make a cake with a slogan supporting same-sex marriage was not discriminatory. The five justices of the Supreme Court were unanimous in their judgement.

The two directors of the bakery are pious Christians who oppose the notion of same-sex marriage as being inconsistent with their religious beliefs. Therefore, when Mr Lee, a gay man and active member of the LGBT community in Northern Ireland, asked for a cake to be decorated with the caption “Support Gay Marriage”, the bakery declined to do so on the basis that it was a Christian business.

Mr Lee saw the bakery’s refusal as an affront to his sexual orientation and consequently brought proceedings against it for discrimination. Judge Brownlie of the Belfast County Court held that, although the bakery would have supplied Mr Lee with a cake that did not have such a slogan and would have also refused an order for a cake with the same message from a heterosexual customer, the bakery’s refusal was because it opposes same-sex marriage which is indissociable from sexual orientation. The bakery appealed to the Northern Ireland Court of Appeal which held that Judge Brownlie had been correct to find that there had been direct discrimination on the grounds of sexual orientation.

The UK’s highest court, however, had an entirely distinct view on the matter. Lady Hale, giving the Supreme Court’s unanimous judgment, explained that the bakery’s objection was to the message on the cake, not to any personal characteristics of the messenger or of anyone with whom he was associated. The court, therefore, held that there was no evidence that the bakery had discriminated on the ground of sexual orientation.

Not only has the cake at the centre of this dispute, which originally would have cost £36.50, proved to be the most expensive in UK history, it has also raised concerns amongst the LGBT community and Equality Commission about the application of equality law in the commercial sphere.

Read more on the Lee v Ashers Baking Company Ltd 'Gay Cake' case here.

Read the latest Employment Views & Insights
They seek to understand their clients and advise accordingly to achieve the outcomes that they require for their business needs.
Chambers and Partners
SA Law Work Life red mug and glasses
SA Law Red arrow neon light image
Views & Insights
Data Protection and workplace coronavirus testing

Managing the data protection challenges of workplace coronavirus testing

Read More
Stained glass window Employment SA Law
Views & Insights
Guidance for enabling a safe “return to work”

A guide to returning to work safely for those who are unable to work from home.

Read More
Stained glass window Employment SA Law
Views & Insights
BP Fuels Diversity and Inclusion Drive

Partner and Head of Employment & Data Protection Chris Cook comments in Personnel Today regarding BP's announcement of their new Diversity & Inclusion…

Read More
Phone Box with Man in a Bowler Hat
As there is so much expertise on offer from SA Law they can provide a legal expert on all areas so that it can be handled under one roof.
Legal 500
Stained glass window Employment SA Law
Views & Insights
Covid-19 and home-working mental health for the insurance industry

Keely comments on mental health issues faced by home-workers in the insurance industry plus duty of care and handling HR issues remotely during covid-19.

Read More
Stained glass window Employment SA Law
Views & Insights
Updates to off-payroll working in the private sector

Following the delay to the introduction of off-payroll working in the private sector, the government are introducing some amendments to the original proposals,…

Read More
Stained glass window Employment SA Law
Views & Insights
Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme: update affecting notice periods

The Treasury has published a further Direction to provide rules that will govern the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme (CJRS). Most of the rules in the…

Read More
Stained glass window Employment SA Law
Views & Insights
Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme: Updated Guidance on Flexible Furloughing

Under the flexible furlough scheme, employees can work for some of the week and be furloughed for the rest, in proportions decided between employee and…

Read More
They are knowledgeable, with a commercial mindset, but also down to earth and friendly so it is easy to be very honest with them.
Chambers and Partners

© SA LAW 2020

Every care is taken in the preparation of our articles. However, no responsibility can be accepted to any person who acts on the basis of information contained in them alone. You are recommended to obtain specific advice in respect of individual cases.