Bellman v Northampton Recruitment Ltd – Vicarious Liability at the Office Christmas Party

Mon 19th Dec 2016

The High Court has held that a company was not vicariously liable for the violent assault of an employee by its Managing Director at a drinking session which followed the company’s Christmas party.

This case provides some much needed clarity as to the boundaries of the rule regarding vicarious liability which can see employers absorb liability for the acts of an employee, committed "in the course of employment" provided that the acts were "so closely connected with the employment that it would be fair and just to hold the employers vicariously liable".

Facts

Following Northampton Recruitment Ltd’s (the Respondent) Christmas party, around half of the guests went on to a hotel for, what the Judge described as, an "impromptu drink". It was not a planned extension of the party, although the Respondent did pay for the relevant taxi fares and it was expected that it would pick up the bill for some of the drinks too.

In the early hours, a controversial discussion began in relation to the recruitment of a new employee. The Claimant, Mr Bellman, challenged the Managing Director on a point he had raised, which appeared to cause the Managing Director to lose his temper. The Claimant was punched twice resulting in his fall to the floor which rendered him unconscious. The Claimant was described as having been bleeding from the ears and suffered severe brain damage as a result of the attack.

The Claimant brought a claim for damages against the Respondent on the basis that it was vicariously liable for the Managing Director’s actions.

Decision

The High Court dismissed the claim and held that the Respondent was not vicariously liable for the assault on the Claimant.

The Court's reasoning for this was that the assault occurred at a spontaneous event which was not part of the work Christmas party, despite the fact that some of the bill was expected to be met by the Respondent. In addition, the mere fact that the assault had followed a discussion of work matters did not mean that it was necessarily "in the course of employment". The incident had arisen in the context of "entirely voluntary and personal choices" by those who attended the drinking session.

Whilst there was sympathy for the Claimant’s situation (given that, by the time of the hearing, the Managing Director was no longer a party to the proceedings on the basis that it was felt he would be unable to pay any award of financial compensation), the Court held that the proper application of the principle of vicarious liability meant that boundaries of the rule could not be extended in this case.

Comment

Given the terrible career-ending injury suffered by the Claimant (who has no other apparent source of compensation), it seems entirely possible that this finding will be the subject of an appeal.

Notwithstanding the findings of this case, which makes clear that the scope of the rule regarding vicarious liability is not endless, employers should nevertheless exercise caution when engaging in activities which could be caught by this rule.

This decision does not change the law in respect of vicarious liability and does not clearly establish that post-Christmas party drinks are outside the scope of employment for vicarious liability purposes (as each case must be examined on its facts). It is therefore essential, especially in the run up to Christmas, that company policies are up-to-date and cover the type of behaviour which is expected of employees when representing the interests of the business, whether during its organised events or otherwise.

CONTACT CHRIS

If you would like more information or advice relating to this article or an Employment law matter, please do not hesitate to contact Chris Cook on 01727 798098.

© SA LAW 2025

Every care is taken in the preparation of our articles. However, no responsibility can be accepted to any person who acts on the basis of information contained in them alone. You are recommended to obtain specific advice in respect of individual cases.

Read the latest Employment Views & Insights
SA Law Red arrow neon light image
Views & Insights
Handling personal data within GDPR

Frequently, employers receive Data Subject Access Requests (DSAR) from their employees or former employees. These are requests for information about personal…

Read More
SA Law Employment Laptop
Views & Insights
National Minimum Wage increase from April 2025

Government announces new minimum wage rates

Read More
SA Law Employment Laptop
Views & Insights
National Minimum Wage: 371,000 workers underpaid in April 2024

The Low Pay Commission (LPC) estimates that around 371,000 people were underpaid in the year to April 2024. The figures published in the Compliance and…

Read More
SA Law Employment Laptop
Views & Insights
Tesco Fire and Rehire Disallowed Rules Supreme Court

In Tesco Stores v Union of Shop, Distributive and Allied Workers and others, five Justices of the Supreme Court reimposed an injunction preventing Tesco…

Read More
Stained glass window Employment SA Law
Views & Insights
Amendments to the Employment Rights Bill

In October, the Government published its landmark Employment Rights Bill. See our article on this topic: “New Employment Rights Bill: Key Implications…

Read More
SA Law Employment Laptop
Views & Insights
2025 Employment Law Changes: Rate Changes

This is an update to our previous article (How the Autumn Budget 2024 Impacts Employers and Employees) to factor in the new rates in relation to family…

Read More
Stained glass window Employment SA Law
Views & Insights
Comments About an Employee’s Accent Could be ‘Related to’ Race Under Harassment Law

In Carozzi v University of Hertfordshire and another, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) held that the Employment Tribunal was incorrect to find that…

Read More
Stained glass window Employment SA Law
Views & Insights
How to Support Neurodiverse Employees

There are common struggles when it comes to businesses managing employees with neurodiversity. From neurodiverse employees not wanting to mention they…

Read More