Bearing the brunt of business rates

In the case of Newbigin (Valuation Officer) v SJ&J Monk (A Firm) [2015] EWCA Civ 78. The Supreme Court confirmed that vacant buildings undergoing refurbishment are not necessarily liable for business rates.

Background to the Newbigin Case

In 2010 SJ & J Monk, the ratepayer of a vacant floor of an office building planned to redevelop the floor into three self-contained units. In order to carry out these works, the unit was stripped back to a shell prior to creating three office suites.

The ratepayer argued that, due to the physical state of the property i.e. that it was “beyond repair”, it should be deleted from the rating list whilst works were ongoing and therefore it should not be liable for rates.

The valuation officer argued that the building was capable of being put back into its former state economically and thus it should remain liable to pay business rates. Initially, the Valuation Tribunal found for the Valuation Office and that decision was appealed to the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber). The Upper Tribunal held that, as the property was not capable of beneficial occupation, the property had a rateable value of just GBP 1.

Court of Appeal Decision

The Valuation Office appealed to the Court of Appeal.

Despite the ratepayer's arguments that the redevelopment works were alterations and improvements that went far beyond repairs, the Court of Appeal agreed with the Valuation Office. In the Court’s view, the replacement of the items which had been removed (the air conditioning system etc) would constitute repairs. It did not matter if these items were going to be replaced just that it would constitute economic repairs if they were to be replaced.

The Supreme Court Decision

The Supreme Court unanimously allowed the ratepayers appeal confirming that buildings undergoing significant works of refurbishment or development to an alternative use will not be liable to pay rates whilst the works are being undertaken.

Key points:

  • The Supreme Court placed an emphasis on the presumption of reality which underpins the rating hypothesis. The starting point should be to determine whether or not the property was capable of being beneficially occupied, before going on to determine whether or not it is in a state of disrepair.
  • The decision is good news for developers who want to avoid the cost of paying rates during works. The wise developer should speak to a building surveyor if they are unsure whether the extent of works being undertaken qualify or not. The small-scale refurbishment is unlikely to be sufficient.

CONTACT AMY

If you would like more information or advice relating to this article or a Property Litigation matter, please do not hesitate to contact Amy Sevier on 01727 798033.
SA Law Women in Law Awards Logo
SA Law Commercial property
Views & Insights
Amy Sevier wins the Women in Law Award for Property Litigation

Head of Property Dispute Resolution, Amy Sevier has won a Women in Law 2018 Award from Lawyer Monthly magazine

Read More
Views & Insights
Telecoms operators should be wary of hiding between their statutory powers

A landmark decision is ruled under the Electronics Communications Code, Amy Sevier explains more.

Read More
Views & Insights
What happens when you build without planning permission?

Property Dispute Resolution Solicitor, Eleanor Grindley writes for Prime Resi.

Read More
Views & Insights
Consent to Assign: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly

Head of Property Dispute Resolution at SA Law, St Albans writes in BRC's The Retailer.

Read More
Views & Insights
EPCs and MEEs: What is the change in the law?

Head of Property Dispute Resolution Amy Sevier examines two legal changes that will affect approximately 18% of the UK commercial property.

Read More
Views & Insights
Gore v Naheed - Rights of way

Head of property Dispute Resolution at SA Law, St Albans writes in property Investor News

Read More
Views & Insights
The Electronic Communications Code: What you need to know

Head of Property Dispute Resolution, Amy Sevier examines the changes to the Electronic Communications Code

Read More
Views & Insights
Ground (f) redevelopment: When unconditional intention appears to be conditional

Head of Property Dispute Resolution Amy Sevier writes for Property Investor News on redevelopment.

Read More
Views & Insights
Are you assured of compliance?

Property solicitor Eleanor Grindley sets out obligations under Assured Shorthold Tenancies and explains what tasks, checks and documentation landlords…

Read More
Views & Insights
Introducing Eleanor Grindley

Head of property Dispute Resolution, Amy Sevier introduces the newest member of the team, Eleanor Grindley

Read More
Views & Insights
Tackling some knotty issues

Amy Sevier in the Property Litigation department comments on recent cases in property litigation and explains what this means for you.

Read More
Views & Insights
Buy to Let – My Top Ten Tips

See our advice on Buy to Let and how we can help you.

Read More
Views & Insights
Security of tenure in almshouse accomodation

Amy Sevier writes for The Solicitors Journal and considers recent cases on the reasonableness of service charges, implied terms in contracts and who should…

Read More
Views & Insights
What is digital risk?

SA Law’s “Let’s talk digital” event at the Institute of Directors in London drew a wide range of delegates who came to learn more about the evolving challenges…

Read More
Views & Insights
The Potential Pitfalls of a ‘Virtual Office’

The rise in the “virtual office” allows growing businesses the flexibility to have a city address at a lower rate, however there are some potential pitfalls.

Read More
Views & Insights
Let's talk digital

What risks are today's organisations facing? This is the question asked as SA Law's recent "Let's Talk Digital" event at the Institute of Directors in…

Read More
Views & Insights
Did you know letting out your home could breach your lease?

Property Litigation Senior Associate Amy Sevier explains the potential legal implications of hosting on Airbnb when you own a leasehold...

Read More
Views & Insights
Early Warning

Glenda Ferneyhough discusses a recent case prompting practitioners to draw their clients' attention to the details of a lease, as well as other decisions…

Read More
Views & Insights
Failure to Complete

Lynsey Newman, Consultant in the Property Dispute Resolution team at SA Law, comments

Read More
Views & Insights
Buyer Beware!

Buyer Beware!Anyone who has ever sold or purchased a property will know very well that there is a significant amount of paperwork and communication between…

Read More
Views & Insights
Momentum builds to ease access to telecoms sites

Publication: Planning ResourceA Department for Culture Media & Sports (DCMS) report issued last month proposes a radical overhaul of the Electronic…

Read More
Views & Insights
Getting over the line: What happens when a buyer refuses to pay up?

Publication: Prime Resi

Read More
SA Law Property Litigation
Clients say this firm is highly 'customer-sensitive' and can 'adapt to your style however demanding you're being'.
Chambers & Partners
SA Law Residential Property house image

© SA LAW 2018

Every care is taken in the preparation of our articles. However, no responsibility can be accepted to any person who acts on the basis of information contained in them alone. You are recommended to obtain specific advice in respect of individual cases.